← All guides

From the Media CFO interviews

Film streaming rights: when do two licences overlap?

A broadcaster has licensed a film for a Tuesday night transmission. Can the producer also sell a streamer the exclusive right to show it on Wednesday? Check what the first buyer is still entitled to do on Wednesday. A catch-up right can conflict with the second buyer’s requested exclusivity even if the broadcaster has not yet put the film online.

Interview published in 2019. The worked example and practical explanation are Media CFO editorial context.

Lindsay Conner
Lindsay ConnerOriginal Media CFO interview · 2019

What does an exclusive streaming licence cover?

Start with the viewer. Can they watch only at the scheduled broadcast time, catch up afterwards, or choose the film whenever they like from a subscription catalogue? All three can reach the same screen. In his 2019 interview, entertainment lawyer Lindsay Conner explained why he described a project as a feature or an episodic series: its format alone didn’t tell him where audiences would watch it. Read Conner’s answer on formats and platforms.

A release window is the period set aside for a particular form of release. The licence defines the permitted use and its dates. Exclusivity defines which competing uses are excluded, in which territory and for how long. That restriction can be broader than the buyer’s own service. A holdback is a contractual restriction that delays a specified use. A holdback on subscription streaming and a ban on all on-demand viewing leave a broadcaster with very different options.

How to compare two offers for the same film

In this hypothetical UK deal, assume the producer controls the UK broadcast and on-demand rights for the periods being negotiated, with no earlier grants or restrictions. The producer has signed a licence giving the broadcaster seven calendar days of non-exclusive, free catch-up after a single Tuesday transmission and permitting a subscription service to show the film during that week. The streamer has made an offer. These are terms invented for this example, separate from Conner’s interview. Start a rights grid before comparing the prices.

Illustrative UK licence comparison
Check Broadcaster Streamer
Where? UK UK
What can viewers do? Watch Tuesday’s broadcast, then use catch-up Choose the film from a subscription catalogue
When? Catch-up from 00:00 Wednesday until 00:00 the following Wednesday, UK local time Requested start at 00:00 on the first Wednesday, UK local time. End date to be agreed
What restriction matters? Non-exclusive catch-up. Subscription streaming is allowed Offer asks for exclusivity across all UK on-demand viewing, including free catch-up

The sticking point is the word all. The streamer plans to run a subscription service, but the exclusivity it wants would also cover the broadcaster’s catch-up. An offer limited to exclusive subscription streaming could coexist with free catch-up on these facts. If the signed broadcaster licence itself barred subscription streaming that week, changing the new offer alone would not clear the Wednesday launch.

For your own grid, enter the language versions, the exact start and end times, and the time zone. Check how each contract defines the territory, including any territories bundled with the UK, and what it requires to limit online access geographically. Check the agreement that gives you those rights and any earlier sale. A repeat broadcast could create another catch-up period if the licence allows it.

WIPO explains catch-up rights and competing grants on printed pp. 52–53 of From Script to Screen. For a model of how to organise the grant, see its sample territorial distribution agreement in Annex 2.

How can the producer keep both deals?

Move the streaming launch. Offer the streamer a launch with exclusivity from 00:00 the following Wednesday, once catch-up ends. If the streamer agrees, the broadcaster keeps its seven days and the streamer can begin exclusive on-demand viewing a week later under these terms.

Keep the launch and reserve catch-up. The streamer starts on the original Wednesday. Its agreement expressly allows this broadcaster’s UK catch-up service until the agreed deadline. Ask the streamer to price that narrower offer. If the plan requires changing the signed broadcaster licence, the broadcaster must agree.

Ask the streaming buyer “Would you still want the Wednesday launch if the broadcaster could offer free UK catch-up until the following Tuesday?” A yes gives counsel a specific exception to document. A no sends the producer back to the later launch date to ask what the exclusive first week is worth to this buyer.

Both options are counteroffers to the streamer in this example. If both licences have already been signed, give counsel both agreements to assess the conflict and the changes each party would need to accept before altering either service’s availability.

Conner was talking about matching the time spent negotiating to the protection each client needed and could afford. “Some things just don't deserve 10 weeks of negotiation. Some things do.” Read Conner’s answer on where negotiation pays off. In this example the producer can hand counsel the signed licence, the proposed grant and the seven disputed days. That’s a much easier question to resolve than “Do we own the streaming rights?”

For the wider question of which window to release in first, see the film distribution guide featuring Philipp Hoffmann’s interview. For Conner’s own discussion of how agreements can account for new ways to watch, jump to the interview passage or browse the negotiation reading list.

Keep exploring

Research, insights and market context.

Three more ways to follow the business of entertainment.

AXIOM™Entertainment Wire™

News · Deals · Company research

Research and insights for the entertainment business.

Track news and deals, research companies and explore reports, with links to the original sources.

Explore the Wire

Some research features require a trial or subscription.

News and deals, side by side. Product preview · September 2026.

Vertical Observer Sister publication

The vertical-drama business, quantified.

An independent record of the microdrama industry: platforms, economics, capital, regulation and audiences, with every figure tied to its source.

Visit Vertical Observer
Latest reports, live from verticalobserver.com.